Pinot Noir vs Merlot: Comparison

Drink Comparison

Pinot Noir vs Merlot

The world of wine can be overwhelming, especially when standing in front of a wine rack trying to make an informed decision. Two of the most popular red wines 🍷 — Pinot Noir and Merlot—often vie for your attention. So, what makes these wines distinct and how do they compare? In this comprehensive guide, we delve into the intricate world of these two red wine varietals, comparing their taste profiles, ideal food pairings, popular brands, and much more.

What is Pinot Noir?

Pinot Noir originates from the Burgundy region of France, and its name means “pine and black,” referencing the grape’s pine-cone shape and dark color. This grape variety is known for its delicacy, complexity, and less intense tannins. Pinot Noir often offers flavors of red fruit, earthy notes, and sometimes, a touch of spiciness.

Meiomi Pinot Noir is a great example of a well-balanced wine, known for its lush flavors of bright strawberry, jammy fruit, and mocha. The balance of oak and acidity makes this wine very food-friendly.

Regional Influence

Pinot Noir is sensitive to its environment, with flavors varying greatly depending on where it’s grown. For example, Pinot Noir from Oregon will have more tart berry and earthy flavors, while California variants like Kendall Jackson Vintner’s Reserve Pinot Noir bring forth notes of dark cherries and raspberries. The warmer the climate, the riper and more alcoholic the Pinot Noir tends to be.

Woodbridge by Robert Mondavi Pinot Noir Red Wine

Woodbridge by Robert Mondavi offers a Pinot Noir red wine that exemplifies the richness and variety one can expect from Californian vineyards. This wine is particularly notable for its fruit-forward profile, featuring dominant flavors of ripe cherry and red berry. These fruity notes make it an approachable choice for both novice wine drinkers and seasoned aficionados alike. 

Yet, its versatility doesn’t stop there. Woven subtly into the primary fruit flavors are undertones of toasty oak, lending the wine a layer of complexity. This delicate oakiness enhances the overall profile, giving it not just structure but also a smoky richness that lingers on the palate. Whether you’re looking to pair it with a meal or enjoy it as a standalone sipper, Woodbridge by Robert Mondavi’s Pinot Noir offers a well-rounded, highly enjoyable wine experience.

Barefoot Pinot Noir

For those who are mindful of their budget but still wish to indulge in a flavorful glass of wine, Barefoot Pinot Noir stands as an excellent option. This wine showcases a soft and silky texture that’s very approachable, even for those who may be new to the world of red wines. Its flavor profile is uncomplicated yet delightful, featuring traditional notes of black cherry and wild raspberry. While it may lack the complex layers and depth found in more premium selections, its simplicity has its own unique charm. 

This straightforwardness, combined with its affordability, makes Barefoot Pinot Noir an ideal choice for various occasions. Whether you’re planning a casual weeknight dinner, looking for an easy sipping wine for a weekend get-together, or even hosting a larger gathering where cost and quantity are considerations, this wine has the versatility to suit all these needs without compromising on taste.

pinot noir

What Is Merlot?

Merlot is one of the most popular red wines in the United States, known for its soft, ripe, elegant, quite luscious taste. You can expect flavors ranging from bay leaf, black tea, and vanilla to red and black fruits like cherries, raspberries, and blackberries. Merlot wines tend to be less acidic than Pinot Noir and are often considered easier to drink—a great intro wine for new red wine drinkers.

Where Merlot Thrives

Merlot grapes are less finicky than Pinot Noir grapes and can grow in a variety of climates, which contributes to its widespread cultivation. They thrive in regions like Bordeaux in France, and also in areas of California and Washington in the United States.

Barefoot Merlot

Barefoot Merlot is notably smooth on the palate, presenting a well-balanced combination of fruitiness and herbal notes that make it both approachable and versatile. With prominent flavors of black cherry complemented by hints of fresh herbs, it provides a taste profile that is pleasant yet not overly complicated.

Just like Barefoot Pinot Noir, this Merlot is designed for both the casual consumer and the budget-conscious wine enthusiast. Its well-rounded characteristics make it a superb option for those looking to explore the realm of red wines without making a hefty investment. Furthermore, its balanced nature means it pairs effortlessly with a variety of dishes, from grilled meats to pasta, thereby making it a convenient choice for dinner parties or family gatherings. In summary, Barefoot Merlot stands as a testament to the fact that a good wine need not be expensive, but rather accessible and enjoyable for all.

14 Hands Merlot

14 Hands Merlot is a standout offering that hails from the prestigious Columbia Valley region of Washington State, an area renowned for its favorable grape-growing conditions. This particular Merlot is exceedingly approachable, characterized by its inviting flavors that feature a blend of ripe cherries accompanied by subtle spice notes. These flavors work in harmony to create a wine that is both delightful to the palate and versatile in its pairings.

The finish of 14 Hands Merlot deserves special mention. It is soft, allowing for an easy-drinking experience, yet also firm enough to offer structure and complexity. This balanced finish gives the wine a versatile edge, making it suitable for a wide range of culinary companions. Whether you’re enjoying a hearty beef stew, a plate of rich pasta, or even grilled vegetables, this wine has the adaptability to enhance the meal. Its approachability and versatile flavor profile make it an excellent choice for both the seasoned wine enthusiast looking to explore the nuances of Washington State wines, as well as the casual drinker seeking a reliable, tasty option for any occasion.

Gallo Family Merlot

Gallo Family’s Merlot enjoys a reputation for being a wine that appeals to a broad range of palates, thanks to its medium-bodied, juicy, and fruit-forward profile. Originating from a winery with a long history of crafting quality wines, this particular Merlot is a celebration of ripe fruit flavors, featuring the richness of plum and the sweetness of black cherry. These fruit flavors come to the forefront, captivating the palate and making each sip a pleasurable experience.

But the appeal of Gallo Family’s Merlot goes beyond just its vibrant fruit characteristics. What truly sets this wine apart is its well-rounded nature, highlighted by a touch of spice that adds complexity without overwhelming the fruit flavors. The wine is further balanced by its soft tannins, which lend structure and a velvety mouthfeel without being astringent. This harmonious combination of fruit, spice, and tannic elements creates a versatile wine that can be enjoyed on its own or paired with a variety of foods. Whether you’re looking to complement a savory meal or simply enjoy a glass of quality wine that doesn’t break the bank, Gallo Family’s Merlot offers a balanced, accessible, and flavorful choice.


Pinot Noir vs Merlot: The Main Differences

Understanding the differences between Pinot Noir and Merlot is crucial for both seasoned oenophiles and newcomers to the world of wine. At a glance, Pinot Noir tends to be lighter in body with higher acidity, often revealing flavors of cherry, strawberry, and earthy notes. Merlot, on the other hand, is generally juicier, with a fuller body and flavors that range from plum and black cherry to herbal notes. The tannin levels in Pinot Noir are generally lower compared to the medium to high tannins found in Merlot. These variations influence not just the tasting experience, but also the types of foods that pair well with each wine. For a deeper dive into these fascinating differences, you can visit this comprehensive guide by Wine Folly.


The Heritage of Pinot Noir

Pinot Noir is an ancient grape variety with roots that trace back to the Burgundy region of France. It’s considered one of the most challenging grapes to cultivate due to its susceptibility to diseases and climate sensitivity. The best Pinot Noirs often come from cooler climate regions, such as Oregon, New Zealand, and certain parts of California like Sonoma and the Central Coast.

Meiomi Pinot Noir sources its grapes from multiple coastal regions in California, each contributing to the wine’s complex character, thanks to the varying soil types and climate conditions.

The Lineage of Merlot

Merlot also originates from France, primarily from the Bordeaux region. Unlike Pinot Noir, it’s easier to cultivate and grows well in a variety of climates. It’s widely planted around the world, from the United States to Italy to Australia.

Blackstone Merlot, for example, comes from California, a state that has had great success with the Merlot grape. The Mediterranean climate and diverse soil types contribute to the wine’s ripe fruit flavors and smooth finish.

Tasting Notes

The Palate of Pinot Noir

Pinot Noir is known for its light-to-medium body and high acidity. Common flavor notes include red fruits like strawberries and cherries, often accompanied by earthy or floral undertones.

Kendall Jackson’s offering showcases a spectrum of red fruits with an elegant touch of spice and earth, making it a wine of great complexity and depth.

The Flavor Profile of Merlot

Merlot wines typically have a medium-to-full body, with tannins that range from soft to firm. Flavors often include darker fruits like black cherries and plums, sometimes with herbal, chocolate, or vanilla notes.

Josh Cellars Merlot presents a delightful mix of dark fruit flavors along with a touch of vanilla and spice, offering a well-rounded tasting experience.


The Look of Pinot Noir

Pinot Noir wines are generally lighter in color, often exhibiting a translucent, ruby hue. The lighter color is a result of the grape’s thin skin.

Barefoot Pinot Noir is a great example, often appearing lighter in color but offering a depth of flavors despite its delicate appearance.

The Visual Aspect of Merlot

Merlot wines tend to be darker and more opaque, usually ranging from deep ruby to purple. This is due to the grape’s thicker skin and higher tannin content.

Gallo Family’s Merlot is often a deep ruby, almost bordering on purple, offering a visual hint at its fuller body and richer flavors.

Merlot vs Pinot Noir


Serving Pinot Noir

Pinot Noir is best served slightly chilled, around 55-60°F. It’s often recommended to serve it in a larger, bowl-shaped glass to better concentrate its delicate aromas.

For example, Woodbridge by Robert Mondavi Pinot Noir would benefit from a large glass to fully appreciate its nuanced bouquet.

Serving Merlot

Merlot is more forgiving in terms of serving temperature, usually best between 60-65°F. A standard red wine glass will usually suffice for Merlot.

Yellow Tail Merlot, known for its easy-drinking nature, is an excellent candidate for casual servings, adaptable to various types of glasses and temperatures.

Ideal Food Pairings 🍴

Pinot Noir

Pairing Pinot Noir is generally straightforward due to its lighter body and higher acidity. It complements dishes like duck, chicken, and even fish like salmon. The higher acidity cuts through the fat, making it a wonderful companion to rich, creamy sauces as well.


Josh Cellars Merlot and Blackstone Merlot are examples of Merlots that are exceptionally food-friendly. They pair well with anything from grilled meats to pizza, making them versatile choices for dinner parties. The Blackstone Merlot, in particular, has a slightly spicy profile, which complements robust meat dishes exceptionally well.


If you are looking for something luxurious yet affordable, consider trying Woodbridge by Robert Mondavi Merlot Red Wine or Yellow Tail Merlot. These wines offer great value for the quality and are easily accessible for any wine lover.

For Budget-Conscious Consumers

Barefoot wines have carved out a niche in the wine market that focuses on delivering quality and flavor at a price point that is incredibly budget-friendly. Both their Pinot Noir and Merlot offerings stand as excellent examples of this commitment to accessible quality. For those who are cautious about over-spending but still wish to partake in a wine experience that offers an enjoyable taste profile, these wines from Barefoot are a perfect match.

Starting with Barefoot Pinot Noir, this wine is lauded for its soft and silky texture, combined with flavors of black cherry and wild raspberry. It’s a wine that brings an uncomplicated, yet satisfying, flavor profile that can accompany a quiet evening at home just as easily as it can a festive social gathering. 

On the other side, Barefoot Merlot offers a smooth and well-balanced palate featuring black cherry and fresh herbs. It has a universal appeal, making it ideal for various occasions and diverse food pairings. The wine is versatile enough to enjoy with a weeknight dinner or to serve at a larger event, thanks to its approachable and harmonious characteristics.

For Those Seeking Quality

For those looking to elevate their wine experience without venturing into the realm of ultra-premium labels, Kendall Jackson Vintner’s Reserve Pinot Noir and 14 Hands Merlot stand out as exceptional choices that offer a noticeable increase in complexity and depth. These wines are thoughtfully crafted to provide a more nuanced and sophisticated tasting experience compared to budget-friendly options, making them perfect for consumers ready to explore wines with greater intricacy.

Kendall Jackson Vintner’s Reserve Pinot Noir

Kendall Jackson Vintner’s Reserve Pinot Noir comes from California’s coastal vineyards, where the maritime influence allows for a slow ripening of grapes, resulting in complex flavors and aromas. This Pinot Noir offers a layered experience, presenting bright cherry and strawberry flavors complemented by subtle undertones of earthiness and spice. The wine’s complexity is also evident in its texture, which balances silky smoothness with just enough tannic structure to add depth. Whether you’re savoring it alone or pairing it with a gourmet meal, this wine is designed to elevate the occasion.

14 Hands Merlot

14 Hands Merlot from Washington State’s Columbia Valley brings its own set of complexities to the table. The wine offers a delightful blend of ripe cherries and subtle spice notes, but what sets it apart is its finish. It possesses a soft yet firm finish that gives the wine its versatility, making it a go-to option for a wide range of food pairings, from hearty stews to pasta dishes. Its well-structured palate offers a depth that makes each sip an exploration of flavors and sensations.

red wines comparison


Choosing between Pinot Noir and Merlot ultimately comes down to personal preference, be it the lighter, more complex flavors of Pinot Noir, or the juicier, more robust profile of Merlot. Both have unique characteristics that make them stand out, and their versatility with food makes them both excellent choices for any occasion.

Zipps Liquor offers a wide range of international and local brands to our Texan community at great prices. Whether you’re interested in trying Meiomi Pinot Noir, Barefoot Merlot, or any of the other wines mentioned, we’ve got you covered.

A Final Invitation

Looking to explore these elegant wines? Visit us at Zipps Liquor—your one-stop destination for all your beverage needs. You can shop online and choose between pickup and delivery, or visit your nearby liquor store in Texas. We offer not just wines but a wide range of beers, spirits, and mixers. Cheers to finding your perfect wine 🍷 match!

Want first dibs on all our specials?
Subscribe to our newsletter!

"*" indicates required fields

Alcohol preferences
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

No spam. Unsubscribe at any time.
By subscribing, you agree to our Terms.

Related Articles

tequila vs whiskey

Tequila vs Whiskey

Mead vs Wine

Honey Mead vs Wine 🍯🍾